Counter-canter is one of the most effective tools for fixing a horse that swaps leads too easily because it directly addresses the underlying cause: the horse does not yet have sufficient rider control over its lead to maintain a specific lead under physical or mental pressure. A horse that swaps leads spontaneously has learned that the lead is determined by the direction of travel or by its own comfort preference rather than by the rider's choice. Every spontaneous swap that goes uncorrected reinforces this understanding. Counter-canter training directly challenges and reverses it — the horse learns through repetition that it must hold the lead it is on regardless of what its natural tendency suggests. Clinton Anderson uses counter-canter specifically as a corrective tool for easy swappers by asking the horse to counter-canter in the situations where it most commonly swaps. If the horse typically swaps in the right lead going toward the gate end of the arena, Anderson puts the horse on the right lead, approaches the gate end, and specifically demands the counter-lead be maintained through that area. Each successful maintenance of the counter-lead in the previously problematic location is a direct correction of the habit. The counter-canter correction is more effective than simply correcting the swap after it happens because it prevents the swap from occurring — the rider is actively maintaining the lead before the horse has the opportunity to swap, which means the horse never receives the relief of the swap and never reinforces the habit. Over many sessions of counter-canter work in the problematic areas, most easy swappers show significant improvement in their correct-lead work as well, because the same mental and physical control that counter-canter develops in the deliberate wrong-lead situation transfers to greater reliability in the correct-lead situation.
Find the Right Trainer
1,700+ verified trainers across Arizona and the Southwest
Find My Trainer →
Watch: How to Use Counter-Canter to Fix a Horse That Swaps Leads Spontaneously

▶
Clinton Anderson: Counter Cantering — Using Counter-Canter to Fix a Horse That Swaps Leads Spontaneously
Downunder Horsemanship