Failing to recognize and address physical pain and discomfort as contributing factors in behavioral and training problems is one of the most widespread mistakes in horsemanship, and it is made with genuine good intentions — trainers and riders typically assume behavioral problems reflect training gaps rather than physical causes and respond with more training rather than veterinary investigation. This assumption is correct often enough to be plausible but wrong often enough to produce significant harm. Horses cannot speak, which means all communication of pain occurs through behavioral channels — resistance, evasiveness, inconsistency, aggression when specific areas are touched, reluctance to perform specific movements, and changes in demeanor or willingness that develop gradually or appear suddenly. Many of these behavioral signals are identical to the signals produced by confusion, training gaps, or attitude problems, which makes the differential diagnosis difficult for anyone who is not specifically looking for physical causes. The consequence is that horses with pain-driven behavioral problems are frequently subjected to increasing training pressure that does not solve the problem because the problem is not a training problem, and that may cause additional physical harm by forcing a horse in pain to perform movements that worsen the underlying condition. The specific physical issues most commonly missed include dental problems that make bit contact painful, back soreness from ill-fitting saddles, kissing spine or other spinal conditions that make collection or rounding uncomfortable, hind limb lameness that reduces a horse's willingness and ability to engage the hindquarters, and gastric ulcers that create generalized discomfort that affects the horse's attitude toward work. Any behavioral change that appears without an obvious training explanation, any resistance pattern that does not respond to correct training approaches, and any horse that is increasingly difficult despite a training program that seems sound deserves a thorough veterinary evaluation before more training pressure is applied. The horse that was treated medically for an underlying physical issue and then retrained from an appropriate starting point is almost invariably a different and much better horse than the one that was trained through pain.
Find the Right Trainer
1,700+ verified trainers across Arizona and the Southwest
Find My Trainer →
Watch: Why People Ignore Their Horse's Pain and What It Costs

▶
Girth Pain, Wither Pain and the Ulcer Connection — Why Ignoring Pain Costs So Much in Training
Equine Veterinary